It was viewed by 8. This episode received positive reviews. Stanley doesn't notice he is drinking Jim 's orange juice, thinking it's coffee, so Jim wonders how much Stanley won't notice. Kevin dresses as Phyllis ; Andy sits at his desk shirtless; Jim places a cardboard box with the computer desktop on it over his monitor; Michael wears fake teeth; Michael talks about a Dunder Mifflin branch on Jupiter during a staff meeting where all the employees except Stanley are facing a different direction; Pam wears a mustache; Dwight brings a pony into the office; and he doesn't notice.
However he does notice when it's p. The office becomes excited over the annual Halloween costume contest when Pam offers a Scranton-area coupon book as the prize for the winner. Of course, this still isn't enough to convince Jim to wear a matching couples costume Popeye with Pam Olive Oyl.
As the day goes on, several people realize their costume might not win, so they leave the office to switch into something more recognizable or provocative. Gabe , dressed up as Lady Gaga , informs the staff of a sales idea being implemented where delivery drivers can suggest additional products for the customers they deliver to. The idea is designed to increase overall sales for the company.
Michael realizes the idea sounds similar to a suggestion made by Darryl a long time ago; Michael, however, initially shot down the idea, believing it wouldn't work. When Jim informs Michael that warehouse worker Madge has made her first sale, Michael decides to confront corporate about stealing Darryl's idea. It is then revealed that Darryl actually pitched the idea to Gabe, who sent it up to corporate, and has already received credit. New salesman Danny invites everyone to a Halloween party at his bar after work.
Almost everyone in the office is aware that Danny and Pam had a two-date fling four years ago. Kevin dressed as Michael Moore and Andy Bill Compton start a false rumor that Pam and Jim don't want people going to Danny's party, which prompts Danny to confront Jim and Pam in order to determine the validity of the rumor.
